What AI Can’t Do: The Human Edge in the Age of Marketing Automation

What AI Can’t Do: The Human Edge in the Age of Marketing Automation

Machines don’t build relationships.

In the world of websites and search, we’re dealing with two audiences.

Humans – the ones who actually buy your products and services. And bots – the search engines that help those humans find you online.

Of the two, the human audience matters most.

Two reasons.

Firstly, and obviously, because humans make the buying decisions.

And secondly, because human behaviour plays a big role in how the bots rank your site. If real people don’t like your website, search engines won’t either.

Going back to basics – what makes someone like your website and choose your business?

A bit like location, location, location in the property game, in this case, it’s relationship, relationship, relationship.

A few more words to add some flavour might be trust, integrity and a solid track record. A belief that you’ll do what you said you’d do – over and over again.

It’s been shown time and time again that machine-generated (AI) text doesn’t build relationships.

AI text fails on two counts. Firstly, the website doesn’t convert to sales. And secondly, it bombs in search because bots don’t rank it.

Sidebar: To see a few famous examples, you can Google any of these

Hundreds of Websites Delisted by Google for AI-Generated Content
CNET’s AI-Generated Articles Contained Errors and Plagiarism
Willy Wonka Experience in Glasgow Misled Customers with AI-Generated Ads

“If real people don't like your website, search engines won’t either.”

Why does AI fail to build relationships with your customers?

So why doesn’t AI-generated content build relationships with your customers?

It comes back to the fact that an AI bot is not a human being. It’s an emotionless machine.

It doesn’t understand your business values and principles. It doesn’t feel emotion or have empathy for your clients’ daily challenges. It doesn’t care if your message converts to sales or if your brand connects with the customers you serve.

Yes, it’s a powerful tool that can generate words at lightning speed. But it’s not a replacement for human insight, empathy or emotional connection.

Your clients buy from people

Your clients buy from people they know, like, and trust. They don’t buy from robots and definitely not from machine generated content.

They appreciate real humans who understand them, who value and nurture the relationship, and deliver on promise.

When your biggest client is making a buying decision – especially for a service that matters – they’re asking themselves one big question:

“Can I trust this business to deliver?”

Their trust in you is built through tone, empathy, storytelling, reputation, and proof of results. It’s not just what you say, but how you say it – and whether those words line up with your business as a whole and how you operate day to day.

Your best clients don’t choose you because you post 10 blogs or social media videos each week.

They work with you because your message connects with them on an emotional level. Because your story complements theirs.

Because your brand feels consistent, credible, and ultimately real.

These are things no AI can fake. And it’s why human-led branding and communication still matter in 2025 and will continue to matter as we march forward into an ever more automated world.

"Your clients buy from people they know, like, and trust—not from robots."

Use AI - don’t let it use you

AI is a powerful tool – its research speed and convergent thinking skills still astound me on a daily basis. And it gets better and better with each passing week.

But at the end of the day, it’s still just a tool.

It can take some of the grunt work off your plate. But it’s not a substitute for experience, empathy, or brand clarity. If you hand over control of your marketing content completely, you risk losing the very thing that sets your business apart – highly effective humans.

My advice is to use AI wisely. Learn how to prompt it at every step so it can help you shape your strategy and content. Let it do deep research and offer structuring advice. Ask it to check your work for errors.

In short, use it to support your voice, not take over the microphone.

Because when humans stay centre stage, that’s when real, lasting connection happens.

“AI is a tool, not a replacement for human experience and empathy.”

About Deb

Meet the author

Deb Croucher is the founder of Brilliant Digital. She works directly with SME owners to create strategy-led, full-service marketing that delivers, not just in Google, but in the new world of AI-powered discovery.

You Might Also Like…

What is going on with AI search?

What is going on with AI search?

What is going on with AI search? I am being asked this question more and more by all stakeholders, not just clients.
Read More
How to write a capability statement that wins business

How to write a capability statement that wins business

While your reputation and website presence are trademarks, prospective clients often ask for a capability statement; they are generally required for tender processes or as part of a formal business pitch.
Read More
Generative AI In Marketing: Practical Tools For SMEs

Generative AI In Marketing: Practical Tools For SMEs

A practical guide to AI tools that small businesses can leverage. Five cases where AI can save time, and five things AI cannot do.
Read More
Voice search and ChatGPT adapting your SEO for conversational queries

Voice search and ChatGPT adapting your SEO for conversational queries

Are you using ChatGPT or other AI platforms and chatbots to search for information? In this article, I provide a practical guide on optimising your website to meet the growing demand for voice and AI-assisted search.
Read More
The human touch in marketing; Trust beats automation

The human touch in marketing; Trust beats automation

Automation and AI are disrupting traditional marketing techniques, but one element not to ignore is the power of trust. You must tell a real story.
Read More
SEO vs. GEO: What Australian SMEs need to know

SEO vs. GEO: What Australian SMEs need to know

For many small and medium-sized businesses, it feels like they have just gotten to know and understand what SEO is. Now there is a new player, GEO!! What is that, and how will it affect my business marketing?
Read More
FY26 Outlook: 3 Digital Marketing Trends Every Business Leader Should Act On

FY26 Outlook: 3 Digital Marketing Trends Every Business Leader Should Act On

AI is rewriting the rules of digital marketing. In this article, I unpack the 3 key trends shaping FY26 and how smart businesses can stay visible, valuable, and ahead of the curve.
Read More
The Enduring Power of Website Content in a Noisy Digital World

The Enduring Power of Website Content in a Noisy Digital World

In this article, I unpack why website content remains the most credible, scalable and effective tool for business growth, despite the digital noise.
Read More
What AI Can’t Do: The Human Edge in the Age of Marketing Automation

What AI Can’t Do: The Human Edge in the Age of Marketing Automation

Is AI helping or hurting your brand? In this article, I explore how to use AI strategically, without losing the human connection that drives trust and sales.
Read More
Optimising Websites for AI Search - Future Proofing your Digital Footprint

Optimising Websites for AI Search - Future Proofing your Digital Footprint

Is your website ready for AI search? In this article, I focus on optimising your website for AI search while maintaining traditional search traction.
Read More

Let’s Grow Your Business Together

Key Takeaways

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Is it okay to use AI in my content at all?

Yes, absolutely—when used wisely. AI can be a great support tool for tasks like research, idea generation, and editing. The key is to keep your human voice, values, and insights at the core. AI should support your strategy, not replace it.

Why doesn’t AI-generated content perform well in search rankings?

Because search engines are built to serve humans. If real people find your content unhelpful, generic, or hard to connect with, it won’t perform well, regardless of how fast or frequently it was published. Google looks for value, not volume.

What do customers look for when choosing a business online?

Trust, consistency, credibility, and a sense of connection. People want to work with businesses that “get” them—brands that feel real, not robotic. That comes from clear messaging, storytelling, and a strong, human voice.

How do I keep my content authentic if I’m using AI to help write it?

Make sure a real human—ideally you or someone who knows your brand inside and out—is shaping the message. Use AI to assist with structure or draft ideas, but always review, personalise, and align the final content with your voice and brand values.

Can I just automate my content to save time?

You can automate parts of the process, but be very careful not to automate your voice out of the message. What saves time in the short term can cost you trust (and conversions) in the long run. People buy from people they trust, not from automated systems.